CRIMINAL PROSECUTIONS BASED UPON A TIME PER PATIENT THEORY
Doctors can be charged with medical billing fraud on the theory that they are billing for more services than they can possibly provide in a single day. This is based on a false assumption - that certain services require a certain amount of time to perform. In this blog, criminal defense lawyer Daniel Horowitz explains why this theory is wrong and doctors are being wrongfully charged with crimes.
Medical fraud billing cases often target individual doctors or smaller practices. For years the false flag of “time based billing” has led to criminal charges against doctors who bill based on complexity and not time. If they are fast and efficient doctors can legitimately treat many patients per hour but they get tagged by insurance companies as “outliers” potentially committing billing fraud. In a certain number of cases this billing dispute escalates and actual criminal charges are filed. This blog explains why these charges should never be brought and it explains why time based billing is an option but not mandatory.
This blog is based upon a case we have in San Diego where state and federal law enforcement operated based upon this false theory. To raise the issue in this case, we hired a top billing expert Dona Hall who wrote a detailed declaration in our case. We worked with medical fraud attorney Drew Bruff and a challenge to the arrest warrant is now pending. Much of this brief is based upon Dona Hall’s expert declaration (essentially reproduced here and annotated by Daniel Horowitz) in a Franks motion filed by Drew Bruff and Daniel Horowitz. Horowitz takes credit for identifying this key area of attack but let’s give credit where credit is due. If you need an expert to objectively review the facts and provide a clear, 100% accurate report, Dona Hall is the person to contact.
Actual Case Pending in San Diego
In this San Diego case the prosecution claimed that our physician client had committed fraud because she billed for CPT codes 99203, 99204, 99212, 99213, and 99214 but did not actually spend 15 minutes per code/patient providing medical services. We challenged this assumption which was actually contained in the arrest warrant affidavit. That affidavit stated that “code
99213 requires fifteen minutes face time with the doctor and code 99203 requires twenty minutes of face time with the doctor. The affidavit’s overarching claim was that each of these five codes “has a time requirement associated with it”. This case involved complicated calculations done by FBI experts who showed that based upon the codes the doctor was claiming more treatments than she could fit into an entire day. Hence the affidavit concluded, there was medical billing fraud.
This assumption of a time required billing is false. None of these codes—not 99203, not 99204, not 99212, not 99213, and not 99214 has ever required a physician to spend a minimum amount of face-to-face time with a patient as a condition of billing.
This face-to-face time assumption is not limited to the case I am writing about. Over five years ago I had another medical trial, this time in San Jose. Four expert witnesses provided to the prosecution by insurance companies made the same assertion. When I probed the source of their assertion none of these experts could point to any lines in the CPT codes that justified their conclusion. What it came down to was that they were trained that this time requirement existed in the codes and their opinion was not based on any independent work on their part, it was based upon essentially a myth that was promulgated by their employers.
Prior to January 1, 2021, CPT E/M office visit codes (99201–99215) included references
to “typical” times in their code descriptors. These typical times were explicitly descriptive averages, not minimum requirements. A physician was never required to spend the “typical” time listed in a code descriptor in order to bill that code. This applied equally to all five codes at issue: 99203, 99204, 99212, 99213, and 99214.
Under the pre-2021 framework, the appropriate level of service for an office visit was
determined primarily by three key components: (1) history, (2) examination, and (3) medical decision making (“MDM”). Time was available as an alternative basis for code selection only when counseling and/or coordination of care dominated the encounter (i.e., comprised more than 50% of the face-to-face time).
This alternative basis works for certain types of medical treatment. An orthopedist who is seeing a patient for back pain may take a lengthy history along the lines of “How has the pain been since your last visit?” and “What type of activities exacerbate the pain?” The orthopedist might have the patient go through a series of movements, go through a medication history and when all of this is done, 15 minutes has easily passed. Rather than document the exam for purposes of hitting the billing factors that justify a certain CPT code, it is easier to document the exam itself for purely medical reasons and justify the code based on time alone. A dermatologist on the other hand can do a cancer skin exam in less than 3 minutes and it is a lot more efficient to bill what was done because a complexity based exam would justify seeing 4-5 patients in fifteen minutes. This may not seem fair and it may be unfair to patients and payors but it is the rule and it is an example of why venture capital groups are flocking to dermatology and avoiding orthopedics. In sum this example means that a physician who spent five minutes with a patient but performed an examination and medical decision making consistent with a 99213 level of service was fully entitled to bill 99213. A physician who spent ten minutes on a new patient encounter but performed the history, examination, and MDM warranting a 99204 was fully entitled to bill 99204. There was no time floor for any of these codes. The same principle applied to 99203, 99212, and 99214. Under the pre-2021 CPT framework, the statement that any of these codes “has a time requirement” is simply wrong.
The AMA Had No Intention of Forcing Time Based Billing
The AMA is behind the time based option (Emphasize OPTION) for billings. Effective January 1, 2021, the AMA implemented significant revisions to the E/M office visit coding guidelines. The revisions eliminated the prior requirement that counseling or coordination of care dominate the encounter before time could be used for code selection. Under the 2021 revisions, physicians now have the choice to bill office/outpatient E/M encounters based solely on medical decision making or on the total time spent on the date of the encounter. It did not in any manner change the option regarding time vs complexity but it completely separated the two and eliminated any sense of time being involved at all. Remember that you can introduce at trial the fact that The American Medical Association (AMA) owns, copyrights and publishes the CPT codes. The AMA comments are the gold standard that all experts rely on.
This time vs complexity issue can be raised by the defense in various ways. In the San Diego case (the first case in this blog) we raised the issue in a Franks motion challenging the arrest warrant. It can be raised before trial through a motion in limine preventing the prosecution from introducing any evidence based on this theory. Tactically you can also allow the prosecution to present this theory through witnesses and then undermine the witness by demonstrating that the theory is completely unfounded. This is a high risk strategy but if a jury understands that a false flag was planted as a key part of the prosecution’s case it can lead to an acquittal or hung jury. One point to remember is that this time vs complexity issue is often NOT the sole basis used by a prosecutor to prove fraud so undermining this aspect of their case may not necessarily result in acquittal. Still such a gross error in a key part of a prosecutor’s case can and will carry over and undermine other parts of their case in a guilt by association type bleed over. It is also an important point to make during plea negotiations. Many prosecutors rely on insurance companies to outline the key elements of a medical fraud case. A prosecutor may have been misled on this time vs complexity issue by an insurance company just as the experts in my San Jose case were “trained” by their companies in this false theory.
If you are a defense lawyer raising this issue an excellent illustration based exhibit is published by the ASHA which explains how a CPT code becomes a code. It is a series of slides and is very powerful when presented to a jury. You can introduce it through your expert. It is accurate and very easy to follow. Remember that the key to introducing this time vs complexity issue to a jury is to make it simple. If the jury understands how CPT codes are created and they understand that the AMA introduced time based billing as a convenience to doctors and as an option, they will get angry at law enforcement agents who failed to follow this "simple" concept.
An AMA publication that also presents well to a jury is actually titled "Are physicians required to document the time spent on each specific task associated with an outpatient visit? Get real answers from the AMA to common myths about documenting the time spent on each specific task associated with an outpatient visit." You can access this time billing vs complexity presentation online. This is part of the AMA's "The AMA's Debunking Regulatory Myths (DRM) series" and it is very powerful in debunking the time required myth. Also, as it is readily available through a basic "Google" search a witness who has advanced a contrary theory can be discredited by simply doing a Google Search in real time in the courtroom and showing how easily the article pops up. You can imply gross negligence by the law enforcement officer and potentially deliberate wrongdoing. The key quote from that webpage is this:
"If using MDM to determine the level of service
- There is no requirement to document the total time spent, and there is no requirement to spend the amount of time correlating with the LOS on the encounter"
There is no rebuttal to this. It is plain as can be in a graphic format. Defense lawyers should use this graphic as very strong evidence in terms of both clarity and presentation style.
If you are considering filing a Franks motion on this issue, take look at our medical fraud/Franks motion blog that we recently posted. With permission of our client who wants to clear her name after negative publicity, we discuss the actual details of that case.
If you are facing medical billing fraud charges either state or federal you can schedule a consultation with Daniel Horowitz by calling (925) 283-1863. Daniel Horowitz is certified as a criminal defense specialist. This is a rare certification and it is earned and issued by the State Bar of California’s Board of Legal Specialization. His practice focuses on representing physicians so the combination of a physician based practice and criminal defense specialization makes Daniel an excellent match for many medical fraud cases.