Contra Costa County Medical Whistleblower Lawyer
What is Health & Safety Code section 1278.5?
Health and Safety Code Section 1278.5 is a California medical whistleblower statute that protects employees or physicians (and healthcare workers) from retaliation when they expose failures in the medical care system. The language is clear:
“[I]t is the public policy of the State of California to encourage patients, nurses, members of the medical staff, and other health care workers to notify government entities of suspected unsafe patient care and conditions.” (Health & Safety Code section 1278.5(a))
What Type of Retaliation is Prohibited under 1278.5?
Retaliation can be of any type. Failure to renew a contract, hostile treatment in the workplace, failure to promote are obvious examples. An excellent list of more covert retaliation was prepared by the CMA (California Medical Association) and adopted by the California Supreme Court in the case titled, Shaw v. Superior Court (2017) 2 Cal.5th 983, [216 Cal.Rptr.3d 643, 393 P.3d 98,)
In Shaw, the California Supreme Court stated:
“According to the CMA [California Medical Association], examples of actions a hospital can take to suppress physician-whistleblowers or to retaliate against them are:
(1) underwriting the salary and/or practice expenses of a competing physician;
(2) establishing a medical care foundation and supporting its physicians with hospital funds;
(3) recruiting competing physicians to the community in the absence of a community deficit for that specialty;
(4) establishing a medical practice administrative service company for selected physicians and charging below market rates so that the doctor keeps a higher percentage of the collections and gains a competitive advantage;
(5) buying the medical building with the physician’s office and refusing to renew the physician’s lease;
(6) inducing primary care physicians to refer patients to the hospital outpatient facility for tests, bypassing the specialist’s office-based testing (e.g., imaging and cardiac tests);
(7) providing special scheduling priorities for hospital facilities;
(8) underwriting certain physicians and empowering them with control or influence over the peer review process;
(9) developing investment partnerships with selected physicians (surgery center, MRI center) that provide lucrative annual returns on investment (e.g., 50% return on investment (ROI) annually); and
(10) providing special equipment leasing arrangements for selected physicians with above market ROI.
California Whistleblower Protection Act (CWPA)
The California Whistleblower Protection Act (CWPA) protects state employees who report dangerous conditions or various violations of the law. The CWPA is found at Government Code sections 8547 et seq.) People who are protected may file a complaint with the State Personnel Board (SPB) concerning the improper personnel action.
Labor Code Section 1102.5
All workers including healthcare workers have protection provided by the Labor Code section 1102.5. This law makes it illegal for employers to retaliate against employees who report a violation of a state or federal law or regulation. This law requires an employment relationship with the person or entity that retaliates. See: Bennett v. Rancho California Water Dist. (2019) 35 Cal.App.5th 908, 911. Labor Code section 3351 has a very broad definition of “employee” so even non-traditional employees may fit. If a person is what we traditionally consider an independent contractor they can argue that they have a type of employment relationship. If this does not apply, but H&S 1278.5 might be a better fit. Labor Code section 1102.5, subdivision (b) requires that the employee engage in “protected activity” such as warning about a violation of law and an “adverse employment action.” These definitions are broadly defined so that most traditional whistleblowing is covered and protected.
H&S 1278.5 which is the medical whistleblower statute does not require an employment relationship but it is limited to actions against medical entities and not individuals who retaliate. Many lawsuits allege violations of both H&S 1278.5 and Labor Code section 1102.5 as alternative theories.
How You Can Protect Yourself
If you are fighting for patient interests and are feeling pushback, you should document all actions that you have taken as a whistleblower and preserve all e-mails (with metadata), texts and conversations that will later support a claim of retaliation under H&S section 1278.5.
If you are experiencing retaliation under the CMA guidelines you should seek immediate legal help to protect your interests. The Horowitz Medical Law Group has the experience to protect whistleblowers and to file a lawsuit to vindicate your rights.
Dan Horowitz handled my complex business issue with magnanimity, compassion, care, promptness, and utmost professionalism. I'm an Attorney and would highly recommend him to other professionals (and others alike) because he's the very BEST at what he does and has an uncanny knack at finding unique resolutions with unparalleled speed and efficiency. What is quite outatanding is that he treats each client with kindness and compassion as if a family member- Lovely K.
I cannot express enough gratitude for the outstanding legal services provided by Daniel Horowitz. He not only possesses an in-depth understanding of the law but also demonstrated a genuine commitment to me. He took the time to listen attentively to my concerns, providing clear and concise explanations of the legal processes involved in my case. He made me feel heard and supported during this tumultuous time. What impressed me most was his unwavering dedication to achieving the best possible outcome for me. The attention to detail and strategic approach to my case were evident at every stage. I am eternally grateful towards Daniel for what he has done for me and I wholeheartedly recommend his services to anyone seeking legal representation. Thank you Dan- Kento T.
Daniel and his team did an excellent job. He was always readily available to take my call and provided peace of mind through a stressful situation.- Reid V.
My experience with Dan was great. I appreciate the knowledge Dan has and the professionalism they exhibit. I would highly recommend the Law Office Of Daniel Horowitz. My family and I are truly grateful we worked with him.- Brandon D.
There are lawyers and then there are real lawyers. Dan Horowitz is a real lawyer in every since of the word. Dan is a Certified Specialist in Criminal Law. You will not find very many attorneys having such recognition especially one that hits on all cylinders as Dan. In addition to his knowledge of the law and his experience, which I found to be unmatched, i appreciated the fact that he at all times is genuine, which for me says it all. Thank you Dan.- Cory N.
“The Best Attorney I Could Have Asked For.”- Katherine Ryken
Dan Horowitz was the best attorney I could have asked for during a difficult time in my career. From the moment I met him, I felt believed, respected, and safe. He and his team were endlessly responsive and empathetic to me and my family. He fought for my case day and night, always keeping my best interests at the forefront of his mind. As I learned from Dan, it is never a good time in oneâ€™s life to need legal representation - but if you need it, Dan is your person, your advocate, and your best friend. We are forever grateful for his tireless commitment to justice for the people.- Katherine R.
He is approachable but serious. Mr. Horowitz is the perfect balance of what someone wants in a lawyer. Not only is he approachable enough to gain and value your trust, but he's a bulldog in the courtroom. Despite his kindness, I have never once doubted his ability to provide me with THE BEST representation in court. I'm so thankful to have found a lawyer capable of such a delicate balancing act.- Molly A.