Skip to Content
Law Office of Daniel Horowitz Law Office of Daniel Horowitz
Call Us Today! 925-291-5388
Top

Physician Beware - The False Claims Act Can Ruin Your Practice

Physician with ears blowing smoke
|

PHYSICIAN BEWARE - THE FALSE CLAIMS ACT CAN RUIN YOUR MEDICAL PRACTICE

What Is the False Claims Act?

The federal False Claims Act (31 U.S.C. §§ 3729–3733) is the government’s primary weapon against fraud in Medicare, Medicaid, and other federal healthcare programs. It imposes liability on anyone who knowingly submits false or fraudulent claims for payment to the government.

Key point for physicians: You don’t need to intend to commit fraud. “Knowingly” includes:

  • Actual knowledge
  • Deliberate ignorance (“I didn’t want to know”)
  • Reckless disregard (“I should have known”)

This low bar makes the FCA one of the easiest statutes for the government to enforce against healthcare providers.

How the False Claims Act Applies to Physicians and Healthcare Practices

Common triggers for FCA liability in medical practices include:

  • Upcoding or billing for services not rendered — Claiming a higher-level service than provided or billing for tests/procedures never performed.
  • Stark Law or Anti-Kickback Statute (AKS) violations — Improper physician compensation, self-referrals, or kickbacks that taint Medicare claims. A Stark or AKS violation often automatically creates an FCA violation.
  • Medically unnecessary services — Ordering or performing tests, procedures, or treatments without proper documentation of medical necessity.
  • False certifications — Signing off on claims that don’t meet all regulatory requirements.
  • Improper supervision or incident-to billing — Issues with physician supervision of mid-level providers.

Penalties are severe: Treble damages (three times the government’s loss) plus per-claim penalties (currently over $13,000 per false claim). A single physician practice submitting hundreds of claims monthly can face millions in exposure.

Civil vs. Criminal False Claims Act: What’s the Difference?

Civil FCA: No specific intent to defraud required. Whistleblowers (qui tam relators) can file lawsuits on behalf of the government and receive 15–30% of any recovery.

Criminal FCA: Requires more deliberate conduct but carries prison time, fines, and exclusion from federal programs.

Many cases start as civil but escalate if evidence of willful misconduct emerges.

Qui Tam Whistleblower Lawsuits: The Hidden Risk for Practices

Disgruntled employees, former partners, or competitors can file sealed qui tam suits. The government investigates in secret, and your practice may not even know until years later. Successful whistleblowers have earned millions, creating strong incentives for insiders to report perceived violations.

Protecting Your Practice: FCA Compliance Tips for Physicians

Strong compliance is the best defense:

  1. Implement a robust compliance program — Regular audits, billing reviews, and documentation training.
  2. Review compensation and referral arrangements — Ensure all physician contracts meet fair market value and commercial reasonableness standards.
  3. Document medical necessity — Thorough, contemporaneous records for every service billed to Medicare/Medicaid.
  4. Train staff regularly — On proper coding, Stark/AKS rules, and reporting suspected issues internally.
  5. Conduct periodic internal audits — Catch problems before they become government investigations.

If You’re Under Investigation or Facing FCA Allegations

Act quickly. Early intervention by experienced counsel can often lead to favorable resolutions, reduced penalties, or case dismissals. The Horowitz Law Group has extensive experience defending physicians and healthcare providers in FCA, Stark, and AKS matters throughout California.

Contact an Experienced False Claims Act Defense Attorney in Lafayette / Contra Costa County

Don’t wait until a subpoena arrives or a whistleblower suit disrupts your practice. Proactive guidance from a knowledgeable healthcare fraud defense lawyer can save you years of stress and potentially millions in liability.

Call the Horowitz Law Group today at 925-291-5388 for a confidential consultation. We serve physicians across the Bay Area, including Lafayette, Walnut Creek, Pleasant Hill, and surrounding communities in California.

Protect your practice. Protect your livelihood. Let our team help you navigate the complex False Claims Act landscape with confidence.